I have completed my wild adventure with Horace Walpole’s The Castle of Otranto (review to post next) as part of my annual mission for Autumnal reading in and around Regency romance. One of the things that caught my immediate attention when cracking open this tome was the preface. First, I found it funny which surprised me; I knew it was more comedic but I did not expect for the comedy to actually strike my dry, modern funny bone. But second, I was surprised that Walpole was spinning his tale as found text or found manuscript.
I am more familiar with modern cinematic found footage than I am with the found manuscript trope, but I am not surprised this convention has its roots in literature. According to a shallow dive, it appears Don Quixote from the 17th century is one of the first modern examples of this trope, although Chaucer’s 14th century The Canterbury Tales has an element of this in its reference to oral tradition. Walpole, largely considered to be the first Gothic novel, established it as a trope in novels that continues to be used today in literature, as well as film, video games and even now AI. As the universe tends to rain synchronicity down on one (or it’s the red car thing of focus), I was enjoying the playlist in an antique/vintage store recently and asked the name for the acid tiki 50s funkadelia, only to discover it was an AI-generated album with the story it was found recordings from an old tropical island radio.
Levy (2020) calls the found manuscript a trope so commonplace by the 1790s that Austen parodied it in Northanger Abbey, only for Cathy to find an old, abandoned laundry list. Levy aligns the trope with romanticism, which makes sense when you consider that some authors and artists used imagery from the past, like the Middle Ages, to evoke themes. Giving the abstract and sometimes supernatural an air of authenticity, especially in the face of modern skepticism vis-à-vis the Enlightenment, the trope no doubt lent credibility to the often fantastical narratives. But this was also the time when forgeries, like the Ireland Shakespeare forgeries, were creating a stir among London society.
Exposure of William Henry Ireland’s forgery of several undiscovered Shakespeare manuscripts unraveled by 1796, around the time Gothic novels were raging in popularity. Ann Radcliffe’s Romance of the Forest in 1791 featured the found manuscript trope, carrying it forward from The Castle of Otranto and establishing it as one possible convention for the gothic novel that would be emulated by countless others, including the gothic chapbooks. There is an element of this in Frankenstein, as it piles epistolary structure upon epistolary narrative and it would resurge in Bram Stoker’s Dracula in 1897. Perhaps the forgery, in some ways, was the point; pushing at learned people to view every text with skepticism and discernment. Or maybe it was just a great way to legitimize the stories. In Ireland’s case, as with many forgeries, I suspect money was the primary interest. The fact that once Walpole was revealed to be the author of Otranto much of the praise for the medieval book turned to scorn about modern romances kind of proves there may have been some insight in the found document scheme.
The Gothic Library has a nice piece reviewing some of the other Victorian novels that would utilize this trope: Gothic Tropes: Found Document Framing Device – The Gothic Library
There would be other genres besides the gothic novel that would utilize the found manuscript as trope, but in the Regency era it was most memorably employed by the Gothic greats and their imitators. To be its a perfect trope for an era deep in tensions between neoclassicism and romanticism.
Levy, M. (2020). Literary manuscript culture in romantic Britain. Edinburgh University Press.
Manuscript Ghosts: Reader and Writer in Romantic Gothic Fiction
Discover more from Regency Reader
Subscribe to get the latest posts sent to your email.









